Article Evaluation Form of the International Journal of Iranian Urban Design Studies (Download File)
- What is the type of the article?
Research Article Review Article
- Does the title, content, and findings of the article align with the field of urban design?
Yes No
- How useful is this article for professors, students, and professionals in the fields of urban design, urban planning, and architecture?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How novel, innovative, and original is the article?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How fluent and clear is the text in conveying concepts?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How coherent is the writing, and how logically structured is the article from introduction to conclusion?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the article’s title reflect its content? If the title is not suitable, please suggest an alternative in the comments.
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the article review previous research, establish a theoretical foundation, and present justified research indicators and variables?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the article adhere to academic writing standards and structural quality (including abstract in both Persian and English, keywords, introduction, main body, discussion, conclusion, and references)?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the article follow appropriate research/study methodologies?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How valid are the data, and how well is the data analysis conducted?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How strong is the article’s reasoning and analytical approach to discussing and evaluating the topic?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the conclusion section summarize findings and provide practical recommendations based on the research results?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the article utilize reliable and sufficient sources related to the topic (in terms of quantity, credibility, and recency)?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How well does the article maintain academic integrity and accuracy in citing sources?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- How accurate and high-quality are the tables, images, and charts in the article?
Excellent Good Average Poor
- Considering that this article is intended for publication in an academic journal, what is your final evaluation?
The article is acceptable for publication in its current form.
The article is acceptable for publication with modifications and revisions.
The article is not suitable for publication in the journal.
